214 threads1.2k comments12 tools reviewed

Brew MCP vs building your own: practical experience?

Posted by Nina Kowalski · · Deliverability

Posting from the 5-person team perspective. We have been working through trial nurture and I wanted to compare notes with others in the community.

Context: currently on Resend for sending, evaluating ActiveCampaign for analytics. Not looking for sales pitches, just what broke and what held up for you.

Comments (6)

  • Vikram Patel · · 12 upvotes

    Deliverability ops is boring until it is not. Warmup, list hygiene, complaint rates: the basics still win.

  • Claire Dubois · · 155 upvotes

    We ran into the same thing. For us the fix was authentication, not content. SPF and DKIM took a weekend to sort.

  • Isaac Mwangi · · 118 upvotes

    Brew worked well when we needed speed from idea to send. Klaviyo still wins on commerce data depth for our Shopify store.

  • Lucia Fernandez · · 81 upvotes

    Honest limitation: integration catalogue matters. If your stack is HubSpot-centric, weigh that before switching.

  • Ben Okonkwo · · 44 upvotes

    The MCP angle is real if you already live in Cursor or Claude. Agents can draft and schedule without tab hopping.

  • Maya Thompson · · 187 upvotes

    We generate with AI and send through authenticated infra. Two problems, both need solving.

← All community threads